Mismatch

From the BBC:

Britain’s armed forces risk falling behind Russia without more investment, the head of the Army will say.

General Sir Nick Carter will say the British Army’s ability to respond to threats “will be eroded if we don’t keep up with our adversaries”.

When I first read this story about an hour ago, they used words to the effect of the British Army not being able to match the Russian Army in battle. Since then the BBC have updated it to the above, perhaps realising they were making stuff up.

But leaving that aside, when have the British armed forces ever been able to match Russia’s? Sure, a platoon from 2 Para or a troop from 42 Cdo would likely make short work of a Russian infantry platoon, but the military as a whole? There may have been a period around 1992 when Russia’s military officers hadn’t seen any pay in over a year leaving half of them flogging weapons out the back of the camp and the rest passed out under a missile silo having drunk a litre of distilled shoe polish, but otherwise the British Army hasn’t been a match for the Russians probably since the Crimean War – and especially not on their turf.

For a start the Russian forces have an overwhelming numerical advantage in terms of men and kit, and even if we allow for the fact that their organisation and logistics is likely shambolic and spectacular SNAFUs will be the norm, they still know how to deploy highly effective artillery and air defence systems when they have to. In addition, even though the average recruit in the Russian Army might be uneducated, undertrained, underfed, and ill-disciplined he will probably have the stomach for a decent fight. By contrast, the British Army is fast turning into a social welfare programme where recruits fret over battlefield prayer facilities and a unit’s success is measured not on how many battles it’s won, but on how much diversity it has in its ranks.

Any role Britain has in opposing Russia will consist in its entirety of supporting the Americans as best they can, assuming our Yank friends are interested in getting involved. Otherwise, if Russia is a genuine threat, we’re probably better off learning a few words of Russian and learning how to drink vodka neat from tumblers than increasing the Army’s budget.

Share

13 thoughts on “Mismatch”

  1. I think that warts and all the British Army would have a far higher chance of winning a war against any foe than their Yankee NATO overlords would ever have. The yanks don’t know how to and have no experience in winning a war, they just cant hack it and have absolutely no chance of winning one on their own and then the Brits can always fall back on a bit of good old Perfidious Albion if needed.

  2. “we’re probably better off learning a few words of Russian and learning how to drink vodka neat from tumblers than increasing the Army’s budget.”

    This sort of defeatist attitude suggests you’re right at home in France.

  3. This sort of defeatist attitude suggests you’re right at home in France.

    Hey, nothing I’d like to see more than the British Army return to being a proper fighting force. But that’s not what the elected representatives of the British people want, it seems.

  4. In all fairness our determination to enlist new recruits to the British Army means our troops will go in hard and strong if the enemy turn out to be white, Christian males.

    For those of another colour and religious persuasion, not so much.

  5. The Russian military is based upon Soviet model, which was inherited from the Tsarist version. The conscription service, of vast majority goes to Army runs like a prison gang. The conscription is 4 years. A 4 year man is the top of the food chain and they gets to order the fresh meat below him. Everyone puts up with this system because if they survive the first year, they will eventually become a 4 year man. I don’t see evidence that the pattern have changed. The Russian Army don’t exactly have NCO system that Western arm forces have, so the jobs that normally would fall into NCO gets handled by junior officers who wants to survived long enough to get out of that racket. Everyone in the chain of command knows what’s happening, but wouldn’t and can’t do much to change it.

    The various services gets their cuts. Navy (the submarine boat service especially as their service is longer) gets the first cut. Strategic Rocket Force, KGB gets the next cut. Air Force the next cut, and everything else goes to Army which is the vast majority. Specialized forces (such as most of what they send out in Crimea and Georgia incursion are not indicative of the effectiveness of the rest of the arm forces.

  6. I have a couple of serving friends and one relative in the forces, snowflakes they are not and nor any of their friends either, regardless of the current adverts.

  7. I thought Yes Minister had pointed this out about 30 years ago… I can’t see much has changed.

  8. /Snark disengaged

    Don’t doubt it.

    But, ignoring the principal/agent problem for a moment, why would a commander of UK Land Forces want his forces to be capable of standing up to the Russkies?

    It’s not as if they’d have to get across Poland, Germany and France first, and then the Channel, surely?

    A somewhat revealing comment, one might believe.

  9. …So you read a few blogs. And then you start to read people’s comments and you find yourself thinking that voluble guy seems to make some sort of sense, mostly, or at least sometimes and only just in a way (and even as you know they are blowing hard for some kind of imagined effect), and then they come out with stuff like this:

    I think that warts and all the British Army would have a far higher chance of winning a war against any foe than their Yankee NATO overlords would ever have. The yanks don’t know how to and have no experience in winning a war, they just cant hack it and have absolutely no chance of winning one on their own…

    How wrong-headed is that? The sharp (and substantial) bit of the US Army (not the socially-engineered back staff, admittedly) is undoubtedly the most fearsome, well trained, motivated and fiendishly well-equipped fighting force the world has ever seen, to date. Honed by harsh experience in Vietnam, Iraq and Afghanistan. Well capable of winning wars, provided they’re allowed to kill most of their enemies. Blessed with the ability to learn, the means to re-invest. Politically hamstrung (as they most definitely should be), periodically inept but, if unleashed, and if push came to shove, awesome and militarily irresistible.

    Expect that in an even earlier vanished internet age, the clucking and complacent druids of the Trinovantes (just made that bit up) confidently asserted that the vaunted Roman army wasn’t really up to that much. Truth is the reasons the ‘Romans’ may have ‘lost’ had little to do with their military effectiveness.

    Imagining for a moment that the deracinated British army can even hold a light to this machine (or more importantly, can effectively confront their real or imagined enemies) is frankly barmy.

  10. Re drinking shoe polish – I once found a bloke dead from drinking it – in the UK. I was in charge of the ward at a psychiatric hospital in the south east, and came on duty in the morning to find that he had been dead probably for most of the night, while the night nurse – we made do with one in them days – was asleep. In that same ward I remember that another bloke died early during the night shift, and was discovered in the early hours. It looked bad on my part, him lying there dead for 2-3 hours undiscovered, so the chief nurse on call who had come to the ward immediately as per regulations suggested that before calling the on-call doctor, we put the bloke in a bath of hot water for a while to raise his internal body temperature. It sounded like a technique he had used before. Those were the days. It was a long time ago, and they’re all dead now – including me.

  11. I have a couple of serving friends and one relative in the forces, snowflakes they are not and nor any of their friends either, regardless of the current adverts.

    I have lots of serving friends who are also not snowflakes, but I’m wondering how representative they are of the overall military and who will replace them when they leave.

  12. By all means let’s fret about a non-existent Russian threat while overlooking the invasion already well underway. Something about motes and beams I think.

Comments are closed.